@Kogard
Difference in our opinion stem from the fact that you can뭪 see where your light HE
shells are landing as well as difference in playstyles.
// Light HE
When I said the difference b/w light and heavy HE is negligible, I offered a simple
explanation after it. Again: the fact that light HE allows you to stay in the game
longer therefore allowing u to rack up more attacks which will more than offset the
difference created by heavy HE.
The difference in range between light HE and heavy HE is at least 2 ship lengths.
This advantage is significant enough to hit other ships with their shells barely
glazing your hull IF you know how to exploit it.
By the way, I said "11"N with light HE gives Scharnhorst bb2-3 range." I never
claimed that it can match range with a BB4/5 as your post indicated.
// Playstyle
Please do not pigeon-hole Scharnhorst to only AA and ASW duty. It's more than
that. At low level, everything below BB is food. Once gunners give tighter spread,
BB1/2 can be potential food.
From reading your post, you observed and seemed to feel that every low tier BB will
stick behind BB4/5s. But you forget the fact that once shells start flying, chaos come
in, some BBs might scatter and some blinded or occupied; it's the perfect time to
snoop in and start hitting them then RUN away quickly.
Scharnhorst can definitely take on BB1/2. And it can harm BB3/4. I never said you
will live through it. I just said you can do damages especially once their SD is gone.
Otherwise I wouldn't be able to do this with light HE:
If you only use Scharnhorst for AA/ASW, you are better off in a D-land.
// FCS & Sailor Levels
밒 read the thread about shells spread(forgot by who, but stickied), ships FCS
contribute 70% of ur spread, and gunner acc ability(or u may call it level) contribute
30%. That's why I suspect Sharn 75 aiming FCS is worse in shells spread than ur
Bizmarck/Opro2 115 FCS, given the same level of gunner.?
You are referring to Adalbert뭩 Ability Guide. When Adalbert refers to FCS, he뭩
referring to +accuracy revision not the FCS space. In the Scharnhorst, it뭩 +75 but
on Bismarck/Opro2 it뭩 +78 not 115.
If you are comparing a BC and a BB3 shooting the same 11?N then yes, the spread
will be tighter on the BB3.
밃nother reason not to use Light HE is your spread is really bad at this level for high
angle shot. I suspect it bcoz of the Scharn FCS accuracy is bad, even with capped
gunner ability.?"
But we are talking about the grind from Scharnhorst/Gnei to Bismarck hence sailor
level (ability) will be the main factor. KM gunners theoretically hit the cap around
from high 60s to low 70s. Let me show you 11?N spread with lvl 71 gunners on
Scharnhorst, it뭩 much tighter than the spread that lvl 62 gunners are capable of
unless heavily vetted.
PURPOSE OF MY POST? PLEASE USE LIGHT HE in primary slot on your 11" N guns.