Please use this topic to discuss the Soviet DD/CL/CA class of ships.
I started with this topic since these ships are least affected by bad crews. I hope to have the crew issues sorted as soon as possible. In the meantime we may be able to do something useful witht he smaller ships.
What do you think about them ? What do you like and what don't you like about them ?
Should changes be made,? If yes, why and how ?
personal opinion: DD1: this one seems fine. I wouldnt change to much here.
DD2: The 2 5.1 sets confuse me a bit. The higher level one looks like the weaker one. In effect there's not much difference to be noticed in battle. I would allways go for the one that looks like an actual turret... It is quite a bit short on Displacement. I could not fit much on the T spots with all sailors loaded. It would need a bit more (350-370 tons). Speed seems ok, with full loadout (and you wont be able to get it lighter by much). Durability could use some work, maybe raise to 7400 ? Turning force down to 28 or 29.
DD3: Leningrad needs a gunspace increase from 50 to 57... that way it would be able to fit the dual 3.9" guns with 3 binds of ammo. The tashkent can use the dual 5.1" and later the dual 6.1" .. it seems strange that the leningrad with 3 R spots wouldn't be able to use dual guns and would be stuck to the low level 5.1 singles and the 6" single. Both of the DD3 could use a small speed reduction, though not to much, since engineers wont be really effective at this level, so the standard calclulation of 1.7*base speed wont go here. Turning force for both should be around 30...
CL1: The Bogatyr seems a bit weak on the R-positions. At level there's really not to much that can be used. The dual 6" come around the same elvel, but with only 2 turrets that's not much effect. The T-positions can be used quite ok for AA with the 'minizini' guns. The turning force could be reduced a bit, maybe from 27 to 24. It is not my favorite ship, but I wouldn't change to much here. The Svetlana is definately the better choice here, even though it is 2 levels higher. Little bigger gunspace, and 6 R-positions instead of 2... Can use 6" duals also. Displacement is a bit low, could use some extra if you want to use equipment on the T-positions. Speed seems ok to me (with at level crew).
CL2: Pallada has a bit of the same story as the Bogatyr... At level there's the second set of dual 6" . Same AA options, not to great, but not a disaster either. Turning force might need a small nerf.
Edit:: after reading some suggestions: Maybe increasing the gunspace on Pallada (and maybe Bogatyr also) to allow it to fit the triple 6". At the same time lower the level of those guns so that they will be available earlier...
|