I personally like 2bis, though I feel like there's something strange about it, likely
perspective wise on the superstructure.

Thank you for your comments :)

i think that you have right, below we can see the ship in the harbor with the original
nose and 2 superstructures. i have to agree that he looks better now. The hull is rounded
around the chemney and the butt has the same high as the front of the ship :



For the sprite battle, i am not as satisfied as the one in the harbor. I am indecisive.


The project 1 is the Core Project
The project 1bis is the project 1 with a more rounded hull around the superstructure
The project 2 is the project 1 with the superstructure's deck lower in high (some px)
The project 2bis is the project 2 with a more rounded hull around the superstructure
The project 2ter is the project 2 with an even more rounded hull around the superstructure

brilliant, love the butt tuck. just like above and give it the original nose job.

personaly i HATE the looks of the Charlemagne, it looks like a floating door wedge.

3 superstructures? It looks butt ugly.

Front is good, rear backside is much better but middle is lacking so much its not worth
changing for me. Kudos on the skill to make this thou.

Great Job M8! :)

nice but 2 things.

1. It looks even more ugly with 2 smoke-stacks (with one it would look sexy)
2.It needs the original nose of the Charlemange

If you fix these things it will look GREAT

try to add the nose from the original charlemagne aswell? cause it still looks alot like
nebby :)

i think this is great :)