Community - Forum - View old data

Categories :  

Test Server Discussion

  Index

  • Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 11. 2011 02:19

mailman
I have had a very long discussion with SDE about what is possible and what is not possible
with the Richelieu.

First of all I had a few options:

1. leave it as it is
2. Change the back 3 R slots into T slots, remove the back R sailor totally and give it an
extra support sailor to compensate.
3. A sort of mix of 1 and 2

After discussing it with SDE, option 2 is NOT possible. It appears a normal ship must have
2 R and 2 T sailor positions. SDE won't allow anything else, as the player might be in
trouble with the next ship if there is only 1 R position and the next ship needs 2. This
kind of makes sense to me. This same request was also refused for NFEU.

Now that got me thinking.

People that have read my previous comments about the Richelieu know that I am quite
annoyed with the 3 rear R positions. Especially now that we have those new 5.1A dual and
quad guns for AA. The Richelieu is the ideal ship for that.

The discussion earlier this morning gave me the following idea:

I included an image for clarity. Red circles would be R positions and blue circles T
positions.

The front R positions would stay unchanged, same for the 4 front T positions.
The 4 mid T positions would also stay the same.
The 3 rear R postions would become T positions (quad AA guns possible)
The 4 rear T postitions would become R (for hedgehogs for instance)



personally I like this way better than it is now with the 3 R positions being used for HH
or even unused at all.

According to the devs this is possible, but they have a concern about it being to powerful
on AA now.

Please give me your opinions about this.
  Index

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 15. 2011 15:18

danita
The Amount of AA shells going up is only the same if you use the 5.1" guns.
If you keep on using the 3.5" you put up 4 shells less for a broadside.
I'd be Ok with that though, since the original Rich put up enough shells as it was
and the flak pattern is improved with the elimination of the gap in the middle of the
AA wall.

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 15. 2011 13:45

richardphat
Like it or not.
This is the solution that will let you firing the same ammount of back T slot and make
it so, you will have always 2 guns firing.


  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 15. 2011 10:42

shamo
do as the charlemagne:

2 main guns, 1 main gunner per gun

everything else: T slot

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 14. 2011 22:33

angus725
Except it was denied by SDE.

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 14. 2011 05:04

Tabihun
2. Change the back 3 R slots into T slots, remove the back R sailor totally and give it an
extra support sailor to compensate.
It's the best idea I've ever heard.

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 13. 2011 09:11

hyz980517
IMO if MN has an aa gun like km40, this aa platform will be a little OP, but since it
doesnt have KM40 so it's just fine

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 12. 2011 17:43

richardphat
Well, not like to go that far.
But either you didn't bother reading his content, read partially, or you are illiterate.

************
2. Change the back 3 R slots into T slots, remove the back R sailor totally and give it an
extra support sailor to compensate.
3. A sort of mix of 1 and 2

After discussing it with SDE, option 2 is NOT possible........

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 12. 2011 15:11

darkangel2
hey mailman make the richelie just 2 guns ship the all other guns make T slost for AA thx

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 12. 2011 13:21

Rick_Rolled
Personally I think the only thing the Rechi needs is a FCS BUFF and as for the aa its
the best in the game with only the back gunz needed (used by the other Main
gunner) and out of all the MN ships this one seems to work the 3.5s the best as the
hit harder do to the grouping of them...Point less to change the AA set up....Just
sayin and I tryed the HH version on the back gunz but it got too complex to use so I
just used the speed instead....with a buff in the FCS this would be the top bb4 or
atleast compareable to the Lion1...

  • Re : Richelieu idea's - comment on this please

    05. 12. 2011 11:47

angus725
I think there was a trip 6" gun that was considered at one point, but generally making new
gunsets/creating guns with the same GA as other guns is quite difficult.
1 2 3