ID
Password
FlashGuide
FlashGuide
HA Infomation

Suggestions

  Index

  • Sonar for scouts

    05. 07. 2013 17:17

Recommend : 0

Anschluss45

BB's have to get an answer for defense against these subs. If you are trying to be realistic, how about a sonar array drop for scouts. Similar to dropping a mine. This would allow a defense net to be established for each team and would add a bit of a challenge for the ss.  Just a thought!!

 

  • Re : Sonar for scouts

    05. 07. 2013 17:22


Billme

already been suggested 45 billion times. also how about some team work?

 

do we not have enough messed up content now that the game is mostly unplayable.

 

lets add more!!!!!!

 

  • Re : Sonar for scouts

    05. 08. 2013 09:45


PictWarrior1

there is no historical basis for this idea, as has been noted every time it's suggested.

  • Re : Sonar for scouts

    05. 08. 2013 19:28


Happymeal2

Its simple rock paper scissors. Rock beats the hell out of scissors and has its buddies hold the 4 corners of the paper down on the table.

  • Re : Sonar for scouts

    05. 11. 2013 23:07


MechPilot524

Originally Posted by PictWarrior1

there is no historical basis for this idea, as has been noted every time it's suggested.



They used sonobuoys in World War 2. In addition, the Japanese and Americans had Magnetic Anomaly Detectors on their aircraft. The Allies actually put a significant priority on equipping aircraft with antisubmarine equipment, as they wanted to detect a submarine (even if submerged) long before a potential target was in danger.(Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-submarine_warfare#World_War_II ) Aircraft carriers such as the Bogue and the Ark Royal gained quite a bit of reputation from submarine hunting task groups.
So, yes, there is in fact a historical background to this to justify any potential implementation of such a system.

Now as to the practical application in NavyField.... As stated above, the implementation of this will not go very well. Some how, some way, the $DE devs never quite put in what they need to the right way. The last thing we need now is another screwup.

And finally. A battleship with half a brain can figure out where a submerged submarine is. Oh, I wonder where those random torps coming towards me came from... It certainly can't be from a submerged submarine! I shouldn't waste my precious PHH on it now, should I? My point being, for what cause would it serve? As when you are being engaged by a submarine you can usually tell where he is.

1