ID
Password
FlashGuide
FlashGuide
HA Infomation

Suggestions

  Index

  • Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 06. 2013 09:22

Recommend : 1

AlexCaboose

Per user. And require people to put a good amount of thought into their suggestions.

 

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 06. 2013 10:16


PictWarrior1

Right, and while we're at it, remove the first amendment too.

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 04:14


normpearii

Originally Posted by PictWarrior1

Right, and while we're at it, remove the first amendment too.



First Amendment does not apply to communication over private infastruture.


Denial of speech by forum communication on private servers does stand in court as not denying the first amendment. There is more than one court ruling on this.

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 04:24


Meastro444

Originally Posted by PictWarrior1

Right, and while we're at it, remove the first amendment too.

Lol. You can't be that stupid, right?

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 09:22


PictWarrior1

You don't get it do you?  What would be the basis of "a good amount of thought"?  And who decides if the thought is "good"?  Would this be an arbitrary decision made by the "experienced" members of the community, such that a new player might have an idea only to be told that he is an idiot and to try again later with "a good amount of thought"?

 

The idea of free speech is such that anyone with a thought in their head might voice that thought and be free to do so without harassment (shy of slander/libel).

 

The very idea of limiting what members of this community might give voice to has already been put in place enough, by mods who believe in "my way or the highway" forum moderation, and by members of the community who believe that only they should be posting because no one else has put in as many hours and years in this game as they have.

 

Is this suggesting that people only come up with one idea per day?  Should they then simply keep a running list of their ideas and only post one per day from their sticky note by the keyboard? 

 

Very often, the author of the suggestion might not know how best to implement the idea, but someone out in the community might.  So they voice their idea, and the community fills it in for them.

 

This post is made likely because someone saw what they deemed to be a stupid idea, in their own opinion, and decided that only the aristocracy of the NF members should be making suggestions.  Because certainly it would be they who determine what is or is not "a good amount of thought."

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 10:51


Cracko

Originally Posted by PictWarrior1

You don't get it do you?  What would be the basis of "a good amount of thought"?  And who decides if the thought is "good"?  Would this be an arbitrary decision made by the "experienced" members of the community, such that a new player might have an idea only to be told that he is an idiot and to try again later with "a good amount of thought"?

 

The idea of free speech is such that anyone with a thought in their head might voice that thought and be free to do so without harassment (shy of slander/libel).

 

The very idea of limiting what members of this community might give voice to has already been put in place enough, by mods who believe in "my way or the highway" forum moderation, and by members of the community who believe that only they should be posting because no one else has put in as many hours and years in this game as they have.

 

Is this suggesting that people only come up with one idea per day?  Should they then simply keep a running list of their ideas and only post one per day from their sticky note by the keyboard? 

 

Very often, the author of the suggestion might not know how best to implement the idea, but someone out in the community might.  So they voice their idea, and the community fills it in for them.

 

This post is made likely because someone saw what they deemed to be a stupid idea, in their own opinion, and decided that only the aristocracy of the NF members should be making suggestions.  Because certainly it would be they who determine what is or is not "a good amount of thought."



  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 14:00


KingCong

A lot of suggestions have been posted before. No one bothers to use the search function anymore. Most of them now are useless repeats, or ideas that have been previously discussed and shot down.

A lot of good suggestions get lost since $de pays no attention to them 

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 14:05


devildog8

so if no one pays attention to them then this thread is pretty usless, hence no one will pay attention to this one either, let ppl suggest what ever they choose, you have the right not to read them just as the have the right to suggest

just because what you claim as not enough thought, doesnt make your argument valid 

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 14:42


AlexCaboose

Originally Posted by KingCong

A lot of suggestions have been posted before. No one bothers to use the search function anymore. Most of them now are useless repeats, or ideas that have been previously discussed and shot down.

A lot of good suggestions get lost since $de pays no attention to them 



Bingo. 

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 19:58


ChicagoBears

Originally Posted by PictWarrior1

You don't get it do you?  What would be the basis of "a good amount of thought"?  And who decides if the thought is "good"?  Would this be an arbitrary decision made by the "experienced" members of the community, such that a new player might have an idea only to be told that he is an idiot and to try again later with "a good amount of thought"?

 

The idea of free speech is such that anyone with a thought in their head might voice that thought and be free to do so without harassment (shy of slander/libel).

 

The very idea of limiting what members of this community might give voice to has already been put in place enough, by mods who believe in "my way or the highway" forum moderation, and by members of the community who believe that only they should be posting because no one else has put in as many hours and years in this game as they have.

 

Is this suggesting that people only come up with one idea per day?  Should they then simply keep a running list of their ideas and only post one per day from their sticky note by the keyboard? 

 

Very often, the author of the suggestion might not know how best to implement the idea, but someone out in the community might.  So they voice their idea, and the community fills it in for them.

 

This post is made likely because someone saw what they deemed to be a stupid idea, in their own opinion, and decided that only the aristocracy of the NF members should be making suggestions.  Because certainly it would be they who determine what is or is not "a good amount of thought."


Don't try and go all lawyer about this, their are some very outrageous suggestions being put out there with ZERO thought put into it.

  • Re : Limit # of suggestions per Week

    10. 08. 2013 21:49


PictWarrior1

Originally Posted by ChicagoBears

Don't try and go all lawyer about this, their are some very outrageous suggestions being put out there with ZERO thought put into it.

 

So ignore them.  That's your right.  :)

1