ID
Password
FlashGuide
FlashGuide
HA Infomation

Suggestions

  Index

  • Remove TK exp penalty

    03. 11. 2014 15:25

Recommend : 8

Celeste_Morn

Was wondering should the TK'ing EXP penalty be removed for good?

 

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    03. 14. 2014 02:54


devildog8

Originally Posted by Meastro444

If you TK someone who has parked himself on the battleline, your stupid fault. You should have watched where your ship is going before you fire.

The idiot running into your torps is indeed annoying, but it happens rarely and is not enough to justify removing the penalty.



rarely? it happens alot more then rarely

and TK if parked? never said anything about being parked, what I said was if your doing everything your suppose to do and some idiot sways in your path then its not your fault

I do agree any idiot parked on the line, is one a very unskilled player, or two not paying attention so he doesnt care in the first place

watching where you are going is everyones responsability, but i dont agree responsable ppl should get burned for the lack of common sence of others 

and i have also suggested taking away Team kill on friendlys, if this was removed, this whole issue would just go down the drain 

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    03. 16. 2014 20:32


KevinJ

Originally Posted by Meastro444

And if you remove any sort of penalty everyone can TK everyone without repercussion, I am sure you don't want that to happen.



Surely you are kidding.

If there were no repercussion for TK, you would not see a huge jump in it outside of dumb hosts for the following reason:

EXP is so linked to winning and losing that TK'ing a friendly hurts you more than enough as a penalty and the TK damage is removed from the team damage exp calculation.

I shouldn't have to waste an entire battle because someone crosses me while I'm looking 3 screens away.

Maybe if you hit them more than once (to prove intentionality) then the exp penalty might occur... but  as it is its stupid, and if someone really wants to TK another person the penalty does not discourage them.

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    05. 12. 2014 15:27


Hellester

I think we should add 'ramming' damage.  If a ship comes into contact with another there will be damage.

 

Unfortuneately there would be no good way to discourage this as an intentional act of tk except to have penalty xp or reporting.  And how would the software/pics determine who is at fault? 

 

I say they work on stabilization issues instead.

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    05. 13. 2014 06:16


jamirogalo

Comedy...

Not recom!!! 

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    06. 02. 2014 23:07


elvintot

Wow another exploit-prone proposal..

If I got a team mate who is eating a bunch of ships and doesnt give any single ship for you to have an attack points I got shot and kill em' or atleast frustrated i could AP or TB him with no sweat.. Specially if you are the ones who are left the room. And make an excuse that oh sorry it was an accident. Oh sorry I didnt see you... etc etc. This can happen also if you devour almost the enemy and you dont want anyone near to kill them. gaining almost everyone in the room without a reason to have an exp penalty for damaging teammates is laughable. Not just TK but also FF(friendly fire).

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    06. 04. 2014 08:19


Ultra_Dog

The person responsible for friendly fire damage is the person who pressed the space-bar.  Any other response is an excuse masquerading as an explanation for your failure.  You have the ability and information to either press the space bar or not press the space bar.  If you press it, you are responsible for what your guns, torps or HH do.  Blaming the errant player who crossed in front of you may be part of the sequence of events, but you are still responsible for your actions.

Magical weapons that can distinguish between enemy and team ships, planes and subs never existed in WWII.

If you were a captain on a destroyer that accidentally shot down a friendly plane or sank a sub or ship or even accidentally bumped into another vessel,  you would be immediately removed from your position as captain, assigned a desk job, had all authority removed, and wait in limbo until charges are brought against you at your court-martial.  That is the fate of officers who make mistakes in the Navy.

TK penalty is proper. 

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    06. 04. 2014 11:10


GINicodemus

I can care less about exp.. If you cross me im tking you reguardless

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    06. 04. 2014 14:40


Billme

sounds good to me. I could spray PHH all over CL, CA, and BB's for shooting down my planes.

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    06. 04. 2014 18:22


elvintot

Regarding the friendly fire damage weither or not that wouldnt change everything and that exp penalty occurs. And yeah we know that we are responsible for pressing space and someone in the team is hit by it. But then again, those who are foolish enough to cross is their mischief and both of them are to blame and its their responsibility. Exp loss or penalty is a must for a punishment for damaging the team mate weither its intention or not.


And by chance I crossed someone and fires at me intentionally and I survive and im in a BB ill screw them with an AP and hope his/her crew gets a death rate regarding if theres no exp penalty. 

  • Re : Remove TK exp penalty

    06. 18. 2014 01:31


SylverXI

I have thought about this couple of time as well and I always conclude that it needs to stay. 

Wheter you TK accidently or on purpose(and make it look like an accident), you need to be punished simply because it's not fair for the player you TKed to be the only one getting punished by your mistake.

The penalty makes people THINK a little before firing when they are crossing. It's better to punish the ones pulling the trigger.

 

Assuming SDE even knows how to remove TK penalty for mines, then yes, TK penealty needs to be removed for mines, but that's not what this suggestion thread is about.

1 2