If you really want to go through the whole ASW vs. SS vs. ASW thing, there are pages of arguing already that you can read.
Lukas has already conceded that ASW isn't always avoidable, and everyone agrees that different conditions and different scenarios can affect the outcome. Some of those things include PHH vs. HH, total number of HH launchers bearing down on you, gradual vs. maximum fire modes, air supply spent reaching the enemy, dive time of a stopped sub vs. moving sub vs. sub using OH... the list goes on.
One side will say "what you said isn't true, not when one of these things is against me" and the other side will say "but you didn't say that before" and someone else will say "yes, you auto-win even despite that thing being against you, if these other two things are in your favour." Then it goes back and forth until people forget the point and bicker about latency on a video capture and the thread gets locked.
So please, let's not rehash that again, since there's pages of it elsewhere already.
|