Community - Forum - View old data

Categories :  

Marine Nationale

  Index

  • MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 07:00

nekoeu
If you think that grind from BB3 to BB5 is horrible enough, then don't forget that the MN
PBB is even worse than Strasbourg and Richelieu, plus the BB5...
I'll compare the Alsace to all the other BB5s, giving you a clear shot at why it's the
worst one.

I've used level 100 guns for comparison and some stats are based on my own experience with
all the ships.




MN has the overall weakest BB5, KM has a true linefighter, RN has the most powerful BB5,
USN and IJN are the most balanced ones.

Even though MN BB5 has great potential to be as a powerful ship as the Montana, the
terrible spread, reload speed and shell damage makes it most of the times damage-wise
weaker than the H44 is. Note that the defensive capabilities of it are also quite bad,
making your SD drop to zero after a full KM lvl 110 gun salvo.

I ommited AAW as all BB5s are unable to shoot down capped fighters/bombers at lowest
altitude (well, they will after long time...)



This topic is not intended to become a flame war of any kind. It's supposed to give an
insight on why the MN BB5 needs to be fixed/balanced.



EDIT: Just for the so-called "lulz": Monty and H44 (lvl 100 guns) reload faster than
Richelieu crapquads.
  Index

  • Re : MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 17:02

cpt99117733
You were doing fine untill this

"KM has the strongest BB5"

  • Re : MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 16:35

nekoeu
I did not disregard it. I marked is as avarage (orange colour) as it's got the longest
range while having the weakest damage. Reload and max angle aren't better either.

  • Re : MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 15:37

PlanZ
As a fellow Alsace player I will comment on the following. You completely disregarded
each other nation's AA capabilities. The French nation gets the longest ranged AA in
game and while it may lack in punch makes up for range.

  • Re : MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 15:21

nekoeu
It's based on the info provided by NF website and/or Trainworld.us.

  • Re : MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 14:56

RSX1
Quick question where are you getting the damage per shell/salvo values from?
because they look kind of odd, besides that yeah it would be cool if MNs BB 5
could at least recive NA stats.

  • Re : MN vs other nations' BB5s (comparison)

    10. 21. 2010 10:50

japex
"G=green, O=orange, N=neutral, R=red"

lol of course.
1 2 3